The big idea

A hard shake chills, dilutes, and aerates in one motion — citrus, egg, or dairy. Stop when the tin hurts; after that you’re mostly adding dilution, not chill.

Shake cloudy or acidic builds; stop when the tin is painfully cold (~10–15 seconds).
Pack with ice — sparse ice melts too fast and warms the drink.
Fine-strain drinks served up to catch chips and pulp.
Spirit-only classics usually prefer a stir for clarity and denser mouthfeel.

The rule

When to shake

Shake when the drink includes citrus, egg, cream, or anything you want fully emulsified. Air and ice do the work — you get chill, dilution, and texture in one motion.

Pack, rattle, stop when it hurts

Pack the tin
Ice to the brim — sparse ice melts and warms.
Shake hard
10–15 seconds, loud rattle, until the tin hurts.
Strain promptly
Fine-strain if it's served up.

Fill the tin with ice, seal hard, and shake vigorously for about 10–15 seconds. Aim for a loud, even rattle — not a gentle rock.

Strain promptly. If the recipe is served up, fine-strain to catch chips and pulp.

Common mistakes

Too little ice → pack the tin.
Sparse ice melts fast and warms the drink.
Loose seal → reseat and shake hard; sprays mean energy (and drink) is escaping.
Shaking a Martini or Manhattan → stir instead when you want clarity and denser texture.

In the glass

Practice shake

Read the drill, then make the drink once focusing on that cue — repetition beats another paragraph.

Rum

Daiquiri

Shake until the tin hurts. Make one at ~8 seconds and one at ~15 — taste warmth versus water, then lock in the painfully-cold cue.

Whiskey

Whiskey Sour

Citrus plus optional egg. If you add white, dry-shake first; the wet shake is what chills. Foam should sit, not scum.

Tequila

Margarita

Hard shake, fine-strain if it’s up. If it tastes dull, check the lime before the tequila.

Gin

Clover Club

Raspberry and egg want a vigorous shake. Thin pink liquid means the foam stage was rushed.

Browse more methods →

In Your first month at home, Sours mastery · Library